It is December of 1792. Elizabeth Middleton leaves her comfortable English estate to join her family in a remote New York mountain village. It is a place unlike any she has ever experienced. And she meets a man unlike any she has ever encountered—a white man dressed like a Native American: Nathaniel Bonner, known to the Mohawk people as Between-Two-Lives. Determined to provide schooling for all the children of the village, Elizabeth soon finds herself locked in conflict with the local slave owners as well as with her own family. Interweaving the fate of the Mohawk Nation with the destiny of two lovers, Sara Donati’s compelling novel creates a complex, profound, passionate portait of an emerging America. [Summary from B&N]
I loved Into the Wilderness. Loved. Which means a couple of things in regards to this review: one, it is likely to be incoherent and, two, it may be unconvincing because I will fail to impress upon you why I loved it so much. But this book? It consumed me.
Nathaniel Bonner is the son of Hawkeye and Cora Munroe from James Fenimore Cooper’s The Last of the Mohicans. He is…Incredible. (My inclination here is to gush and sigh like a schoolgirl, but I’ll try not to. Know that that is exactly how I feel on the inside, however.) Nathaniel, like his father, knows firsthand that the world is not fair, that people are not kind, and that you have to protect what is yours – including your beliefs – with ferocity of mind and body. He is unflinchingly strong, determined, fair-minded but suffers no fools, devoted to his family, and is capable of rousing…well, everything.
“Tell me you don’t want to kiss me,” he said, his thumb stroking the curve of her cheekbone.
“I can’t,” Elizabeth said hoarsely. “I can’t tell you that.”
“Then do it,” Nathaniel whispered. “Kiss me.”
Startled, Elizabeth pulled away a little. Nathaniel was looking at her with an intensity that frightened her, and she saw that he meant it, that he was waiting for her to do this. His fingers threaded through her hair. He waited; she knew he would wait forever. She could do this, and take what she wanted, or walk away, and live without it.
But Elizabeth being the strong woman that she is, knowing perfectly well what she wanted above all else and despite the fact that it went against beliefs she had held nearly all her life, takes it. And the love that she and Nathaniel shared gripped me, moved me; I will never forget him, them. I can’t put it into words, how the romance in this book swept me up, and it is with great hesitance that I even type the word “romance” because it isn’t right. And I don’t want to scare you off by using it. But let me just say this: Nathaniel knows how to speak to a woman, and I have several pages tagged so that I can go back to them again and again.
While this novel has a strong romantic element, it is not the sole premise, and there is adventure to spare. Elizabeth and Nathaniel, specifically, endure awful trials, and they bear the scars of their physical and emotionally journey. In that respect, this book isn’t easy. You will cringe, you may find yourself outraged, but you will always be emotionally wrapped up in the events that unfold. That was one of the novel’s biggest appeals for me: It played to all of my senses, pulled all of my emotional strings, but I never felt as though the author was trying to manipulate me into feeling. That could, in part, be chalked up to the era and the setting, when travel was arduous, when men were a bit rougher around the edges, when the law wasn’t such a strong presence or could otherwise be made to look the other way. The pieces fit and the ev
ents were believable enough.
Into the Wilderness is almost 900 pages long. The action ebbs, and while you readily turn the pages, it can’t be rushed. The characters carry you through. Urge you to keep on. Without having finished it, I ordered the second book in the series, Dawn on a Distant Shore, and I can’t wait to read it.
It’s not a perfect book, but for me? For the emotional impact it had? It was just right.
Looking this over, I realize this review is incredibly reserved. All the time I was writing it I was thinking: “NathanielSiiighhhNathaniel!!!!!” I’m even hesitant to hit ‘publish’ on this post because, you know what? I don’t really want to share him. Yes. He’s that good.
(Also, the cover above is on the recently re-released trade paperback. I read the mass market and I’m not sure which cover I prefer, but I think they say different things about the book. Neither gets it quite right, but I do have a fondness for the paperback, mostly because it was in those pages that I found something wonderful.)