Comfort reads. Is there a reader who doesn’t have one or two, maybe more? Perhaps, but if it’s so, that reader isn’t me. And it isn’t Shannon from Giraffe Days, either. A post on her blog – a lovely blog, I might add, that I eagerly check most every day – not too recently focused on her top ten comfort reads. I thought: I can do that. But as it turns out, I can’t. At least not easily.
Why? Well. These books- the ones that offer comfort – fill me up. I think about them and it’s like something inside of me is expanding, my feelings like air in a balloon, pushing and demanding. Like a string tying off that balloon, I try to wrap my mind around each exhale of emotion. And I can’t. I’ve never been able to blow up a balloon to its fullest. Asthma. And I expect that no matter how many times I try to write it, I’ll never get this post just right.
But what I can do is scale it back. Try to focus on a couple and stretch the theme into several posts. So that’s what this is, the first post and two books that have long since been cemented as comfort reads.
Before I get to them, though, I’m going to borrow Shannon’s definition of what a comfort read is. She nailed it.
“What is a comfort read? That’s an easy one. It’s a book that, no matter your mood, you can snuggle down with. A book that you know, because you’ve read it before, has the power to absorb you, de-stress you, shine a little light on your soul for however long. It’s a book where the characters are like family, a book that has associations and memories for you – good ones. A book that’s like your best friend, like a cuddly old jumper that you will never throw out no matter how tattered it becomes. It might be an ugly edition, it might have water damage and dog ears and wrinkles on the spine, or it might be immaculately preserved (especially if you’re as careful with your books as I am!).
A comfort read is, quite simply, a book you read to comfort yourself with. You know what happens but that’s never a problem. It’s the characters and the story that you love, like a favourite movie or comforting song. And, for me, I think it needs a happy ending. I want to be left with that feeling of wholeness that is happiness.”
There is a faded receipt within my paperback copy’s pages. It’s been mostly stripped of its print, but you can just make out the store’s name, the price of the book; I’m sorry to say that the date is gone, worn away after all this time. A couple of weeks ago I opened the book for a re-read; I came to that receipt and smiled. For no particular reason other than it was there and it was a touchstone to the day I bought it, not knowing what awaited me, how deeply I would come to care about Claire and Jamie. How consumed by it, by them, I would become. As I began to read, I realized it was as true now as it had ever been, and that my emotions were as firmly tied to the story as they ever were. Moreso. Because now I do know them. I know what bits of dialogue turn me inside out, or cut me. I know there are scenes that flicker behind my eyes like a film strip, so clear, and that I don’t need to actually read one again to recall it in a blink.
Reading Outlander was a perfect experience for me. And because it was it scared me; as a result, I put off reading the next book. Eventually I did, but it shook me up so bad I didn’t continue from there. Until recently. After that re-read I made a decision: I wasn’t going to put off reading Voyager any longer. And that’s what kept me occupied all of last week. But that’s not this post, that’s another; hopefully I’ll get it written and posted this week. Suffice to say, I’ve fallen even more in love. And I’m just as scared as I was after that first, brilliant read through of Outlander.
Perhaps its odd that something that riles me up so much can comfort as well, but it does. Does it ever.
Since they are in a few small ways similar, I have to mention Sara Donati’s Into the Wilderness; I read it just this year, but reading it again means falling for it again, each time. It belongs on this list, too.
The Black Jewels Trilogy by Anne Bishop
If you’ve read my blog for any length of time this can’t come as a surprise. But I have to mention it here, again.
The omnibus edition is 1204 pages long. I carried it around in my bag for weeks while I read it and then after. I couldn’t let it go. I didn’t want to part from it. There are times still that I find myself standing in front of the shelf it sits on, running my finger across its spine. Because I need to be close.
The books that make up this trilogy harbor several of my favorite characters of all time: Lucivar, Daemon, and Saetan. I can’t imagine my life without them and their world in it. They both may have their brutal moments, their darkness, but there is so much tenderness and passion in these pages, and when I’m settled among them I always feel safe and happy. Content.
Truth told I could have included all of the companion books because I pick them up again and again as well, and love them nearly as much. More truth? Ms. Bishop could write a single page and so long as it was a scene shared by the three listed above, I would be blissed out.
So there it is. Inadequate. But I’ll be back again with part two sometime in the near future. In the meantime, tell me which books are in your comfort read category?

Thanks for the compliment Chelle, I’m really touched! Nice start to the morning
I loved Outlander – like you, I had to take a BIG break after #2 … and it’s been I think three years. 2007, I read the first two. I’m definitely ready for Voyager now; I just never have the time! I loved how you said, “I know there are scenes that flicker behind my eyes like a film strip, so clear, and that I don’t need to actually read one again to recall it in a blink.” I have books like that – and this would be one of them – that I still have scenes in my head from, crystal-clear.
I absolutely loved the Black Jewels Trilogy too – I know what you mean when you say “They both may have their brutal moments, their darkness, but there is so much tenderness and passion in these pages, and when I’m settled among them I always feel safe and happy. Content.” I haven’t re-read them, and I have more books in the series to read too, but the characters have become favourites of mine and I love the tenderness and passion. That one scene where Daimon and Jaenelle finally realise their love – that scene was small but seemed to grow huge in my chest! I carried it with me for days, keeping me warm
Looking forward to reading about your next comfort reads! Great post Chelle!
oh gosh, I really really must add Outlander to my list! Soon.
I saw a complete set of the Black Jewels trilogy in the bookstore earlier today and I wanted to grab them already! But I just bought several books last week.
This is an excellent post! I’d love to come up with a list of comfort reads. Some that I could think of off the top of my head are the Queen’s Thief series by Megan Whalen Turner, Crown Duel by Sherwood Smith, The Blue Sword and Beauty by Robin McKinley, the Kate Daniels books by Ilona Andrews… and the list will probably go on and on. I look forward to your next comfort reads post.
Totally second those selections!
I’ve never read Outlander, but I guess I really should. I’m re-reading Jaran by Kate Elliott right now – I’d forgotten how good this book is, definitely a comfort read! It’s out of print, but Mistwalker by Denise Lopes Heald is and will always be a comfort read!
My two go to comfort reads, would be the Song Of The Lioness series by Tamora Pierce and An Offer From A Gentleman by Julia Quinn. I have read both of these so many times I could piratically recite the book, but I love them. And they get a 5 out of 5 rating every time I read them.
I love this concept of comfort reads. I may do a post on this sometime if that’s okay.
You haven’t read the rest of the “Outlander” series? Really? Truly?
Wow. I’m actually a little jealous because you’ll be coming to the adventures all fresh (and won’t be waiting 4-5 years between books). As F. Scott Fitzgerald once said:
“It is invariably saddening to look through new eyes at things upon which you have expended your own powers of adjustment.”
‘Outlander’ is my no. 1 comfort read, for sure!
My copy was bought second-hand from Amazon, so it’s a little bit battered. After I read the book I remember holding it in my hands and thinking “who was stupid enough to give this away?”
I can open that book (actually any book in the series) at any page, read any random paragraph and know what is going on. I’m that intimate with the story. I still cry at all the same places too.
GREAT post!
All three of these books would be on my comfort reads list.
I devoured the Outlander series when I first started reading them, to the point where I had to ensure that I didn’t buy the next book in the series until Friday night. If I bought it earlier in the week I wouldn’t actually sleep because I had to see what happened next. Voyager is one of my favourite books in the series so I am glad that you have read it now.
I don’t often reread, but I reread both Outlander and Into the Wilderness earlier this year, and they both stood up to repeat reads! I was intending to continue on with both series, but other books I hadn’t read yet have gotten in the way. I will get to them eventually.
As for Black Jewels, I struggled with the first book, but once I got to the end, and understood the world a bit better, I absolutely loved them. Must be nearly time for me to read the next book in the series for me.
Shannon – You love the Black Jewels, too?! Makes me even gladder to have found your blog!
Not everyone has loved the companion books, but I didn’t see their flaws; I was just too thrilled to be back, to be given the chance to visit again. Oh, and there are scenes! Scenes that broke my heart and sewed it back together tighter than ever. Especially between Lucivar, Daemon and Saetan. You have those to look forward to!
And I took a huge break between the Outlander books – over ten years! But I’m so glad to have read Voyager now and I cannot wait for The Exile graphic novel (being billed as Jamie’s side of the story) to be released this September! I’ve been scouring the web for pages and the few I’ve seen have only whetted my appetite.
Charlotte – If you do decide to read it, try to find a time when nothing else is pressing. It’s loooong, but if you’re like me you’ll find it impossible to put down.
Chachic – I must read some of those books you listed! Especially the Queen’s Thief series. Totally agree with you about Kate Daniels. And you’ve got some willpower there! I have to resist buying a *second* copy of the Black Jewels trilogy every time I step foot in a bookstore.
Wendy – I’ve never heard of those two, but I’m going to have to check them out. I am, however, looking forward to Kate Elliott’s new one, Cold Magic. Have been hearing wonderful things about it.
Rebs – Agreed on the Song of the Lioness series! I only recently discovered it, but I blazed through them and adore the characters and world. And I’ve got several romance novels that make my list, but, surprisingly, I’ve never read anything by Julia Quinn. Looks like I might need to remedy that.
Holly – Absolutely! I’d love to read that post.
Danielle – Nope, but I’m changing that. I already own all of them – having bought each new release – but I kept shying away from them. No longer!
I’m going to space them out – since they’re all so long – but I’ll read them sooner rather than later now. And I cannot wait for The Exile!!
Marg – You are so right: Both books completely stand up to rereads. I love how their grip hasn’t lessened and I suspect it never will. And now I want to pick one – or both – up again!
There’s a graphic novel from Jamie’s perspective coming out?! I hadn’t even heard! Oh I absolutely have to get that!
And … 10 years is a really long time!! I don’t feel so bad now
[...] random thoughts This seems to be a topic that’s getting around. I just read posts on it here and here, today. I was wondering if I actually have comfort reads. I don’t re-read too much [...]
This series is definitely one of my all time F-A-V-O-R-I-T-E stories!
My first time in the Blood realms was Dreams Made Flesh which I picked up on a whim and didn’t give much thought to for a while. When I did.. OMG! I had to read the whole series . I still re-read them and I’m glad to see (in reading your blog) that I’m not the only one who re-arranges the order of the books to vary the read… makes it all the more fun
Just found out about Twilight’s Dawn. I’m so happy to be going back there!