Publisher’s Summary:
“October ‘Toby’ Daye is settling into her new role as Countess of Goldengreen. She’s actually dating again, and she’s taken on Quentin as her squire. So, of course, it’s time for things to take a turn for the worse.
Someone has kidnapped the sons of the regent of the Undersea Duchy of Saltmist. To prevent a war between land and sea, Toby must find the missing boys and prove the Queen of the Mists was not behind their abduction. Toby’s search will take her from the streets of San Francisco to the lands beneath the waves, and her deadline is firm: she must find the boys in three days’ time, or all of the Mists will pay the price. But someone is determined to stop her-and whoever it is isn’t playing by Oberon’s Laws…”
My biggest obstacle when approaching this review is how to refrain from sounding like a broken record. Stellar series such as this one, the kind of series that maintains an unrepentant level of quality, that imbues each new release with narcotic delight, forces the reviewer to scour her vocabulary, searching for a word or phrase that hasn’t already seen the light of day in a review that came before the one in progress, hunting for a word that complements the high bar set by the author’s work. It’s not an easy task. It is, in fact, so daunting, it makes me want to throw in the towel and say, simply but emphatically, “Oh, for the love of – Just read these books! Thank me later.” So close. But I can’t because Toby, Tybalt and Seanan McGuire deserve more from me than that.
It frustrates me to do so, but let me recap my still-stands sentiments regarding the series to date: Toby is one of my favorite UF heroines, hands down, having won me over with her vulnerable strength and determination, her ability to get knocked on her ass and struggle up, and her unswerving devotion to those she cares for; Tybalt, King of Cats, is one of my favorite UF heroes, hands down, having claimed me with his sexy-as-sin ways, his dedication to his people and those he cares for, his belief in Toby, and his, well, everything; Seanan McGuire’s absorbing world-building entranced me, not being a reader who generally takes note of such things while reading, and continues to get better, deeper, and more vital with each book; and, finally, there’s the host of secondary characters that burrowed under my skin from book one and won’t let go. Reading that back, it merely scraped the surface of my sentiments, but my point is fairly plain: The October Daye series is necessary to me and my reading life. I love it. I crave it.
One Salt Sea cemented Seanan McGuire’s status as one of the best urban fantasy writers today, and not because it was the best book in the series, per se, but because she took me places I’d not thought to go, and because the story told in the pages of this particular book teased my emotions in unexpected ways. To take up the middle portion of the previous sentence – took me places blahdy blah – I’ll refer back to my claim that this series’ world-building is entrancing and raise it now to downright wondrous. McGuire took me under the sea. When I was younger and my family visited EPCOT, there was a ride – Horizons, unfortunately gone now – that gave you a choice: space, the desert, or under the sea. Pick one and see what it might be like to live there. Nine times out of ten I chose the sea. I wanted to know what it would be like if I were inoculated to the dangers of no air, able to move effortlessly through the water, unaware of its pressure on my body, and this despite my Jaws traumatized state of being. Seeing it through Toby’s eyes, so tactile, so wouldn’t it be something if it was just like this, turned me into a little kid again, giddy at the prospect of exploring something beautiful and new. Granted, Toby had her hands full and wasn’t able to stay long, but her time in the Undersea Duchy of Saltmist made me as happy as the proverbial clam. Come to think of it, any time Toby visits some place new, be it the Shadow Roads or Goldengreen, I feel just so. The world-building is that good, I swear. Now, as for the latter part of the first sentence in this getting-longer-by-the-second paragraph, I can’t say much for fear of spoiling some BIG things, but let’s leave it at this: while my mind is firmly, and I do mean firmly, set, I felt a momentary pang of emotion that, for a quiet moment, leveled me. Just like that. And now, more than ever, the possibility of what might come next leaves me breathless.
For all that happens, and while I can’t explain it, One Salt Sea felt like a more subdued story. Hushed even, at times. Little things affected me more than ever before, particularly involving Quentin, Toby’s friend and newly appointed squire, and Raj, Tybalt’s sweetly fierce nephew. Those two almost – almost – match Tybalt’s hold on me. I also increasingly find myself enjoying the friendship that Toby and May, former fetch turned roommate, have settled into; it’s perhaps odd how blind I am to female friendships in UF books, usually because the friend has annoying tendencies that make me want to slap her silly and so I gloss over it, but that is not the case here. And my hope that characters introduced in this installment return in future books is not unwarranted as McGuire’s track record of not creating an inconsequential secondary character is still going strong. They all mean something to Toby, for good or ill, and have a place in her world and life, which I heartily appreciate.
Now, you didn’t think I’d be able to wrap up this review without mentioning Tybalt, did you? Even if it is just to say that the very thought of him makes me want to purr like the cat I am not but he most assuredly is. As ever, I loved every second Toby and Tybalt shared the same space, every time Toby thought of him, every word Tybalt said, and he had some deliciously heartrending and mending things to say (more of those little things affecting me hugely), and every action he took to protect her. And what makes matters more amazing? Knowing that we haven’t even begun to see or know all that he is. Oh, Ashes of Honor, you cannot find your way into my hands soon enough.
Did One Salt Sea offer everything I’ve come to expect from an October Daye novel? Obviously, I’d say. Did it give the love I carry inside of me for Toby, her friends, and her world a booster shot? Absolutely. Do I think you should find a copy of Rosemary and Rue, the first book, and set down with it, comfy and with hours to spare, to discover her and them and it for yourself? Well, yes. Can’t you tell?